Deputy hits back at criticism over low proposition count

Friday 04 October 2024

A Reform Jersey politician has responded to concerns about the low number of propositions brought to the States Assembly this year, arguing that there are other ways to create meaningful change and measure political effectiveness.

St Helier Deputy Carina Alves took to social media on Wednesday to defend the broader responsibilities of local politicians.

The number of propositions lodged by States Members this year – 71 so far in 2024 – has fallen significantly below the annual average of over 100. 

But Deputy Alves said: "The role of a Parliamentarian is not simply to lodge propositions. It is also not the sole way to effect change."

Pictured: A proposition is a proposed piece of legislation that allows States Members to introduce debate topics for the Assembly to vote on.

She added that much of the work done by Deputies happens "behind the scenes", and does not require formal debate in the Assembly.

This, she explained, includes conducting scrutiny reviews, holding meetings with constituents and stakeholders, and influencing internal government policies—all of which, she argued, can lead to significant progress without requiring a formal debate in the Assembly.

Deputy Alves, who has served for six years, also said that the propositions she has brought forward were always "well-researched and targeted."

???? Really disappointed to see reports that a fellow Deputy has called for colleagues to "get off their backsides and start working" in response to the low number of propositions lodged.

pic.twitter.com/RiGIVMwUCO

— Deputy Carina Alves - Reform Jersey (@DeputyAlves) October 2, 2024

She added: "My work output, and that of my colleagues, should not be measured by the number of propositions and amendments we have done, but on the positive effect on change and people we have had."

Deputy Alves suggested that the criticism might indicate a need for "wider public awareness and training for Deputies of what the role of a Parliamentarian actually involves and the ways we can effect change".